Author: Rachel

• Born: August 4, 1888
• Died: November 29, 1941 (Buried at St. Mark’s Lutheran Church, Pennsburg)
• Spouse: Alice H Fox
  • Born: October 1, 1884
  • Died: June 12, 1948 (Buried at St. Mark’s Lutheran Church, Pennsburg)                                            
• Married: Date unknown
• Occupation: Cigar maker, silk mill weaver, worker in a trunk factory
• Children: William, Margaret, Russell

---

The oldest child of William and Mary Thomas, Philip was born on August 4, 1888 in Bronx, NY.  He most likely attended school and may have worked in a cigar factory alongside his father.  

In his late teens, Philip moved back to Pennsylvania with his parents and younger siblings.  He returned to work in factories but did not continue school past his second year in high school.  The 1910 census lists Philip as a boarder in another family’s home (the surname is unfortunately illegible) on Main Street in Red Hill.  At the time, he was 22 years of age and worked as a cigar packer in a cigar factory.

Philip married Alice Fox, who was born on October 1, 1884, and whose life and lineage is detailed in the FOX portion of this site.

Considering how recently Philip Thomas lived there is a surprising lack of information about him as a person.  His youngest son, Russell Thomas, does not have very much to say about his father’s life when asked:

“What I know mostly about my father was that he was from Tylersport… He was just a factory worker.  He worked in the trunk factory in Pennsburg. That’s burned down. Then he was in textiles. You know, they had those silk mills around here.  A lot of time he was unemployed… during the depression.”

Russell also recalls that they moved around a lot when he was young. Census records also reflect the family’s financial difficulties and Philip’s unsteady employment during the Great Depression.  

In 1920 the family lived at 149 Main Street in Pennsburg. Philip was a cigar packer in a cigar factory.  Although addresses may have changed since that time, modern maps show 149 Main Street as not too far from the house where Alice Fox, Philip’s wife, grew up: 70 Main Street, just across from St. Mark’s Lutheran Church.  

By 1930, the family lived at 584 Main Street in Pennsburg.  At this time, Philip was a weaver in a silk mill, and his daughter, Margaret, was a cutter in a knitting mill.  According to the census, the family’s monthly rent was $18. Sometime before 1935 the family also lived on Seminary Street, as Russell recalls walking with his mother from his home on Seminary to visit his maternal grandmother, Rebecca Hess, at her home at 70 Main Street.  His mother also worked at a cigar factory across from the railroad station on Seminary Street. Their stay there must have been short lived, however, since this address does not appear on any census records.

 By 1940, the family lived at 434 Main Street in East Greenville and Philip continued to work in a silk mill.  Alan Thomas, grandson of Philip Thomas, recalls that the house was half of a twin and had only coal stoves in rooms rather than central heating.  Interestingly, this house is only a handful of doors down from the Heimbach residence, where Russell’s wife, Pearl, grew up.

Philip died on November 29, 1941 of a heart attack, as did his father and grandfather.  There is some speculation within the family that the economic hard times and his periods of unemployment led Philip into a habit of drinking.

One could say that factory work was a way of life for the extended Thomas-Fox family.  The undated photo below is the only photo anyone has of Philip Thomas. Also pictured is his cousin, Charles.  Philip and Charles were married to sisters Alice and Andora Fox. All worked together at what is believed to be a factory on 4th Street in Pennsburg.

After his death, Philip’s wife, Alice, became diabetic and remained at home.  She was taken care of by her daughter, Margaret, until Alice’s death on June 12, 1948.  Both Philip and Alice are buried at St. Mark’s Lutheran Church Cemetery in Pennsburg.

The Children of Philip Thomas & Alice Fox

Philip and Alice had three children:

William Thomas

Margaret Thomas

Russell Thomas

• Born:   October 1861
• Died: 1918 (Buried at St. John’s Lutheran Church Ridge Valley, old cemetery)
• Spouse: Mary Veth
  • Born: 1867 in New York City (Buried at St. John’s Lutheran Church Ridge Valley
  • Died: 1848
• Married:      1887
• Occupation:  Cigar maker in the Bronx, NY; Cigar maker at Allen Cressman’s Sons Cigar Factory, Tylersport, PA; Night watchman at the tower of the Philadelphia and Reading Railway Company, Sellersville, PA.
• Children:    Philip, Anna, Ellen, William, Milton, Jeremiah, Harvey, Jacob, Charles

---

William Thomas was born in October 1861, most likely in or near Tylersport.  As a young man he moved to the Bronx, NY, where he worked in a cigar factory.  It is possible that both he and his younger sister, Hannah, traveled to New York together in search of work as industry began to boom after the close of the Civil War.  However, although Hannah lived in the city at the same time, also married in New York, and returned to Pennsylvania sometime before 1920, she has not been found in any New York census records between 1880 and 1910.

In 1887 William married Mary Veth, who was born in New York and was the daughter of German immigrants John (b. 1827) and Rosanna (b. 1831) Veth.  According to the 1900 census, the couple and their first five children lived at 629 East 153^rd Street.  Google images of this address now show empty lots where houses once stood, and the neighboring streets are full of buildings, now either vacant or occupied by stores and apartments, that were likely factories around the turn of the twentieth century.  Which one was the workplace of William can only be speculated. On a neighboring street is the old South Bronx High School building, now the Mott Haven Village Preparatory High School, which their older children may have attended. This neighborhood is near the modern Yankee Baseball Stadium.

By the 1910 census, William and Mary had returned to Salford Township, Pennsylvania, and lived on Allentown Road (near or in Telford and near the Ridge Valley church) along with their first five children and Mary’s mother, Rosanna.  Back in Pennsylvania, the couple had four more children. William returned to work at Allen Cressman’s Sons Cigar Factory. His oldest daughter, Anna, also worked in a cigar factory at this time.

---

The Family’s Home

Years ago, William & Mary’s grandson (Henry, son of Jacob) gave me a copy of a photo of what was referred to as the Thomas’s inn or hotel. Henry and my grandfather both said that Jacob owned and lived at a hotel or inn in Tylersport:

Obviously, the hunt for this home began. But it also quickly ended, because with nothing other than the town of Tylersport to go on (and living in another state, myself), it was a 100-year-old needle in a haystack.

Earlier this year (2022), with vague recollections of something about this home being at the top of a hill, and something about the roads Ridge Road and County Line, I literally scrolled around on Google Maps. While there is a crossroads of Ridge Road and County Line Road in Tylersport – with a sizable old tavern still existing on one corner, two old homes on others, and one empty lot – the buildings there were no match.

Then it dawned on me that census records in the 1900s began including addresses.

In 1910, William & Mary and their 9 children (and, presumably, their daughter Ellen’s husband) lived on Allentown Road in the township of Salford, having moved back to Pennsylvania from the Bronx in the last decade. In 1920, William was deceased, but Mary continued to live on Allentown Road with several of her children (including Anna’s husband and son).

By 1930, censuses added house numbers, and the family is listed at 51 Allentown Road in Telford. The head of household was now 28-year-old Jacob, son of William and Mary, along with his wife Miriam and their first two children, Pauline and Ruth. By 1930, Mary was living elsewhere with her daughter Anna and son-in-law Henry Fitzgerald. According to Thomas Chappell, one of their great-grandsons, Mary had a stroke “shortly before 1940” which left her an invalid and unable to speak.  Anna and Henry took care of her 6 days a week. Mary’s other daughter, Ellen, and son-in-law Norman lived at the adjacent address and took care of her on Saturdays. 

Google Maps has become a great tool for locating old family residences. Allentown Road has since been split into a “north” and “south.” Only North has a 51, and the dwelling certainly did not resemble the photo above. However, one just a few doors down did:

And there she is. The bricks have been whitewashed, the trees have grown, but the lovely trim and path and even diagonal gutter on the side of what is now 39 N Allentown Road are exact. It is maybe 2000ft from that intersection of Ridge and County Line Roads, and very near the church that William, Mary, and many more generations attended and are buried at. According to Zillow, the home was built in 1900 and now has 4 bedrooms. For a family at the turn of the 20th century, it seems a large home. But, William and Mary did have nine children who lived here.

But was it an inn? I’m not convinced, even though the tale of the inn comes directly from Jacob’s son. Census records and his obituary list Jake as a butcher or factory worker. No mention of an innkeeper, and I doubt he would have had time to run an inn with a factory job and, as was typical for the time, food to grow and livestock to tend. That said, censuses make it sound as though Jacob was an independent butcher; perhaps he worked from home and could have overseen boarders. The home certainly could have had room to spare for a traveler or two.

At the intersection of Ridge and County Line there is an old tavern, which was almost certainly an inn at the time. Perhaps someone in the family worked there, or perhaps its proximity just led to a story not exactly rooted in fact. Since Jacob died in 1993, we probably won’t ever know.

---

William lived to be 57 years old.  Late in life he took a new job as a night watchman in the tower of the Philadelphia and Reading Railway Company at Sellersville.  This job was not a long-lasting one, however; according to his obituary, William suffered a heart attack his second night on the job, and his body was found in the watchtower by the day watchman upon arriving to work.  This was in the year 1918, though the exact date of William’s death is unknown. William was also a member of the Tylersport chapter of the Patriotic Order of the Sons of America, which published an additional obituary.

Following William’s death, Mary continued to reside on Allentown Road with her children.  Mary died in 1948 at the age of 81. She and William are buried at St. John’s Lutheran Church in Ridge Valley, near William’s parents.

The Children of William Thomas and Mary Veth

Philip, the oldest child of William and Mary, is discussed here.

Anna O., the couple’s oldest daughter, was born in October 1891 in the Bronx.  After returning to Pennsylvania she worked in a cigar factory. She married Henry H. Fitzgerald at St. John’s Lutheran Church in Ridge Valley on February 22, 1912.  They had two children, named Henry and Charles. Anna died in 1978 and is buried with her husband at St. John’s.

Ellen F. was born on January 14, 1893 in the Bronx.  She married Norman Royer in 1910, after returning to Pennsylvania.  They had three children named Norman L., Russell S., and Mary. She died on July 14, 1962, and is buried with her husband at St. John’s.

William J. was born in August 1895 in the Bronx.  Like his father, he was a member of the Patriotic Order of the Sons of America.  He died at the age of 22 of pneumonia and is buried alongside his parents at St. John’s.

Milton J., often called “Mook” by his family, was born in March 1897 in the Bronx.  He married Elsie Klein on August 1, 1929 and had two daughters named Esther and Mary.  He died on August 5, 1970 and is buried in Christ Union Cemetery in Trumbauersville. 

Jacob, also known as Jake, was born on February 5, 1902.  He married Miriam Nase (born Dec. 5, 1903; died June 11, 1997; daughter of Charles & Carrie Nase) and had seven children: Pauline, Ruth, Mary, Jacob, Janet, Henry, and Carl.  According to his son, Henry, Jacob owned and lived in a hotel in Tylersport (see the above story and photo of the purported hotel/inn). Jacob died on March 30. 1993 and is buried with his wife at St. John’s.

Jeremiah, also known as Jerry, was born on November 27, 1903 and baptized at St. John’s on March 20, 1904.  He married Mabel Breisch (born Sept. 17, 1906; died Feb. 25, 2008, at the age of 101) and had three children named Nancy, Paul, and Barry.  Jeremiah died September 8, 1997 and is buried in the Sellersville Cemetery. Russell Thomas once mentioned that Jeremiah had a barber’s shop in his brother, Jacob’s inn.  Russell also recalls some details about the lives of Jeremiah’s three children: Paul, who lived from August 24, 1928 to August 31, 2011, played for the Orioles baseball team when it was a farm team for the NY Yankees.  He died in South Carolina. Barry was a highly acclaimed football player who played for the Citadel. According to Russell, who recalls watching one of his games on New Year’s Day, the “papers were full of him,” and he “could have gone pro but his mom didn’t want him to.”   Nancy left Pennsylvania and moved west.

Harvey was born on September 3, 1905 and baptized at St. John’s on May 27, 1906.  According to Russell Thomas, his nephew, Harvey was a racketeer. He owned a gas station and sold tires on the black-market during WWII, when many such materials were strictly rationed for the war effort.  Russell says that he “played horses” at racetracks and “always had a pocket full of money.” Harvey did marry, though her name has not been remembered by anyone in the family or found in any of my research.  According to Russell she worked in the top offices of Sears and didn’t associate with the Thomas’s very much: “not that she was nasty, she just went her own way… Why she married [Harvey] I’ll never know!” Harvey died on August 9, 1985 and is buried in the Fairview Cemetery in Boyertown.

Charles O was born in 1910 and died in 1944.  He is buried in the St. Philip Neri Catholic Church cemetery in Pennsburg.  All other information here about him comes from the personal knowledge of his nephew, Russell Thomas, and his grandson, Scott Thomas:

Charles O was a great baseball pitcher for the Perkiomen township team, part of what was known as the “Twilight League.”  Russell recalls watching him strike out 17 of 21 batters: “I knew who he was, and I watched him pitch ball when I was around 12 or 14 years old.”     

According to Scott, Charles O met Catherine Klein through her brother, William Klein, who also played baseball.  According to Russell, Catherine lived on Main Street in Pennsburg. He says that she “was on the wild side,” and would often “hang out with a bunch of boys.”  Scott recalls that she was also into bowling.  

In 1933, Catherine had a child, whom she named Charles F Thomas, and claimed that Charles O. was the father.  At the time, Catherine was 17 years old and Charles O was 23. Charles O and the rest of the Thomas family denied that the baby was his son.  He spent a few days in jail for denying the child was his and for refusing to marry Catherine. According to Russell, the incident was “a sore subject in the Thomas family,” who never accepted the possibility that the baby could be a Thomas.  Young Charles F, however, was determined that he was a Thomas. 

According to Scott, Charles F was mostly raised by his grandmother, Amanda Klein (Catherine’s mother).  The younger Charles only saw his father twice: once when he was injured as a child and in the hospital, and at his father’s funeral. 

Charles O later married Anna Welck in 1939 and lived with her, his mother-in-law, and step children on Ridge Valley Road in Salford until his death.  He died in 1944 at the age of 34, some say as a result of alcoholism. 

Like his father, Charles F was also a baseball player, and as a bat boy he met his cousin, Paul (Jeremiah’s son), who later played for the Orioles.  Charles continued to play baseball into his 40’s. He graduated high school in 1952 and joined the army, just barely missing going to Korea. He married Elizabeth Stoudt (b. 1933) and had three children: Sharon, born in 1957; Charles F, born in 1960; and Scott, born in 1963.

Catherine Klein later married Roland Heffentrager and lived on 3^rd street in Red Hill for many years.  She died in 1992, and she is buried at St. Paul’s Lutheran Church in Red Hill.  Scott Thomas, her grandson, had the opportunity to get to know her and says that she was a very sweet lady.

---

Photos

Gravestone Photos

• Born: 1855 or 1856
• Died: January 19, 1886
• Buried: Animas Cemetery, Durango, Colorado        
• Occupation:   Miner

---

For generations, family legends told of a young Thomas who went westward to seek his fortune, but instead met an untimely and tragic demise.  Though many separate tales of “lost Dutchman miners” exist across the western states, one such miner was Henry Thomas, son of Jeremiah and Sarah Ann.  A Dutchman he was not, but rather a man from Pennsylvania, where the German-American dialect known as “Pennsylvania Deutsch” was spoken. Though “Deutsch” is literally the German for “German,” this dialect, and those who spoke it, were and still are often referred to as “Pennsylvania Dutch.”

The Legend

Though the newspaper articles provided here detail the accident in which he died, stories passed through the family instead held a greedy partner accountable for Henry’s death.  The legend as I heard it was passed to my mother, Martha Thomas-Beard by her aunt, Margaret (Thomas) Weisel. Margaret told of a Thomas ancestor who went west to Colorado (whether or not he was the same individual who purportedly escaped west after fleeing prison was unknown but speculated).  Margaret was unsure of what the man’s name was, only that he was a Thomas. She told that Mr. Thomas and his partner discovered a very well loaded silver mine, one that only they knew the location of. While on the way into town to register the mine, thus giving themselves legal rights to it, one partner shot the other, hid the body, and registered the mine in his name alone.  However, on the way back to the mine the partner was struck and killed by an avalanche. It was said that neither his body nor the precious silver mine were ever found. Whether or not this is how the incident truly happened, we will never know. 

The Official Story

Newspaper articles detailing the incident tell a different tale, instead recounting a snow slide which demolished Henry and his colleague Sutton’s cabin, burying him under the snow.  The following articles detail the tragic event, as well as the “largely attended” funeral, complete with brass band.

Four of these articles are from the Durango, Colorado newspaper “The Idea.”  These articles were graciously researched and provided by Ms. Julie Pickett of Durango, Colorado. 

The following articles about Henry Thomas’s death from an unknown Pennsylvania newspaper, as well as translations of the articles into English, were provided by his great-nephew Henry Thomas of Pennsburg (grandson of William H. Thomas and son of Jacob).  

Article translations:

Article 1

A tragic incident.  The frozen Mr. Henry H. Thomas buried.

         We reported a few weeks ago that a snow avalanche smashed the hut of two gold miners in Colorado; that one by the name of Sutton was able to save himself, while the other Henry H. Thomas, son of the Constable Thomas in Tylersport, was unable to get away and had to be left behind by his companion.  When Sutton brought the news to the next settlement of Durango, it caused a great stir, because the people believed that they were perhaps still able to rescue him; and James Bradley, a former companion of Thomas undertook to look for the victim of the accident. He left Durango about 4:00 o’clock on Saturday afternoon on horse and rode to Fort Lewis.  There he took snowshoes and went to Parrott that night. From there William Vailes accompanied him and both of them went early in the morning and climbed up the La Plata Gulch and reach the place of the accident Monday morning at 3:00 o’clock. They found the hut destroyed by the avalanche the way Sutton had described it. The end of the gable stuck out of the snow about 30 feet below the spot where the hut originally had been, and a quantity of dried fruit, sacks for ore, ropes, a wheelbarrow, and other articles were scattered further down the mountain.  By means of a pole they were able to find the body. It lay by the hut under about 10 feet of snow. It lay on its back, stretched out with hands crossed over his chest. He was just wearing a shirt, a pair of pants, and thin socks. His face looked natural.

         Thereupon the men made a sled from the snowshoes, wrapped the body in canvas and started on their way home.  The snow was about 13 feet deep on the even stretches of the way, and about 18 inches of fresh snow fell on Monday.  It was storming terribly all day long. After they had gone 2 (7?) miles, they became tired and exhausted from the storm. They decided to go to the Monitor Mines about 3 miles up the mountain to get help.  In the Monitor Hut they stayed until Tuesday morning, where they were accompanied by the men Righter and Scott in order to return to the place where they left the body. The four men brought the body at 11:00 o’clock at night to La Plata.  Here Hampton and his son joined them and together they all arrived at Parrott and from there the next morning they reached Fort Lewis. From there the military authorities took care of transporting the body to Durango to the morgue. The body thawed out during the night, and the next morning the doctors were able to examine it.  His right ankle was broken and his right arm injured, and the head and other parts of the body were badly scratched and bloody. All the signs showed that Thomas died from his injuries and from freezing. It was the opinions of the doctors that he lived for several hours after Sutton had left him, and if Thomas had been able to wait until the rescue, he would have been able to recover from the injuries.

         The accident victim was the son of Jeremiah Thomas from Upper Salford Township and was about 30 years of age.  He was an industrious man, a good miner, one of the best in San Juan. He had some valuable possessions in that area which his sister in New York will inherit.

Article 2:

Durango, Colorado, January 28^th

         From the extreme southwest part of the state another snow avalanche was reported.  Leonard Sutton who worked in the Silver Lake Basin was in the La Plata Mountains, arrived at Durango last night and reported that last Tuesday an avalanche demolished the hut by Daylight Mine and buried it.  Sutton, who sat with Henry Thomas in the hut, succeeded to dig himself out of the snow. He also found his partner 10 feet under the deep snow, but had to leave him behind due to his broken leg and internal injuries.  Thomas begged Sutton to kill him in order to put an end to his misery. Sutton hesitated to do that. Thomas then asked Sutton to leave him immediately and save himself; in the spring he could return to get the body, and to send his money and possessions to his sister in New York.  Since Sutton believed that Thomas could only live a few more minutes, he gave in to his companion’s wishes and left his partner to his fate.

This article appeared in the New York Herald on January 27, 1886:

Lost & Found

At the time of our communication, Ms. Pickett was researching the names of those interred in the Animas Cemetery whose gravestones have been lost or destroyed by vandalism.  Henry Thomas was one such individual.  His name has since been added to the Animas Cemetery website, which lists all those individuals laid to rest there:

Henry H. Thomas

Born: About 1855 in USA

Died: 19 Jan 1886 in Silver Lake Basin in the La Plata Mountains, CO, USA

Henry was killed by an afternoon snowslide that slammed against the cabin in which he waiting for a snow storm to abate. He was buried under 15 feet of snow, but was dug out by his mining partner who then left him behind at Henry’s request. A short time later he succumbed to the freezing temperatures. Before his partner left him, Henry wrote a letter to his sister Hannah Thomas of New York City. His obituary stated that he was buried in the Animas City Cemetery, but there is no engraved headstone marking his grave.

• Born: May 2, 1831
• Died: July 23, 1903 (Buried at St. John’s Lutheran Church Ridge Valley, old cemetery)
• Spouse: Sarah Ann Hetrich (aka Hotrich or Hetrick)
  • Born: June 19, 1830
  • Died: Feb. 27, 1907 (Buried at St. John’s Lutheran Church Ridge Valley, old cemetery)
  • Daughter of Joseph Hetrick (1803-1894) and Sarah Ann Erney (1801-1885), also buried at Ridge Valley
• Married: January 15, 1853 at the Tohickon Reformed Church
• Occupation: Constable of Tylersport, according to family legend
• Children:    Milton, William H, Henry H, Hannah E, Anna Catharina, Maria Jane, Sarah Alice

---

Sadly, little is known about the life of Jeremiah Thomas except the facts surrounding his family. He was born May 2, 1831 and died July 23, 1903 at the age of 72.  

Legend tells us that he was the constable of his hometown of Tylersport.  He married Sarah Ann Hetrich / Hotrich on January 15, 1853 at Tohickon Reformed Church (now St. Peter’s UCC in Perkasie), the same church at which his father, Nathan, and presumed grandfather, Josiah, were also married.  

His wife, Sarah Ann Hetrich, who lived 77 years from June 19, 1830 to February 27, 1907 is buried alongside her husband and many of their children and grandchildren in the old cemetery at St. John’s Lutheran Church Ridge Valley. 

Children of Jeremiah and Sarah Ann:

Jeremiah and Sarah Ann had seven children.

Milton H Thomas was born on June 9, 1852 and died on August 7, 1904.  He married Mary Schoenly on December 7, 1872. Records indicate that the couple had two children: William (b. 1874) and Charles (b. 1877; married Andora Fox, sister of Philip Thomas’s wife, Alice).  Census records also indicate that Milton worked as a cigar maker in a cigar factory. Milton is buried in the old cemetery at St. John’s Ridge Valley, though the resting place of his wife is unknown.

William H Thomas and his family are discussed here.

Henry H Thomas (though not a direct ancestor) and the circumstances of his life and tragic death are discussed here.

Hannah Elizabeth Thomas was born on May 30, 1862 and died on December 12, 1936.  Like her older brother, William, she lived in New York for several years and it is presumably there that she met her husband, Jacob Kortsteger of Prussia.  It is unknown whether the couple had any children. It was during Hannah’s time in New York that her older brother, Henry, died tragically in Colorado, leaving much of his possessions to her.  By 1920, Hannah and Jacob had returned the Pennsylvania. Both Hannah and her husband are buried in the old cemetery of St. John’s Ridge Valley.

The last three of Jeremiah and Sarah Ann’s children died very young.  Anna Catharina was born on November 30, 1854 and died on January 16, 1855.  Maria Jane and Sarah Alice, twins, were born on October 14, 1871.  Maria Jane died on August 6, 1872, and Sarah Alice died later that same month on August 30.  All three are buried in the old cemetery of St. John’s Ridge Valley.

Jeremiah, his wife Sarah Ann, & many of their children and grandchildren are interred in a family plot in the corner of the original cemetery at St. John’s Lutheran Church in Ridge Valley.

• Born: June 13, 1809
• Died: February 19, 1899 (Buried at Union-West End Cemetery, Allentown PA)
• Spouse: Hannah Renner
  • Born: April 7, 1803
  • Died: Nov. 27, 1890 (Buried a St. John’s Lutheran Church Ridge Valley)
  • Parents: Adam Renner & Elizabeth Renner
• Married:      June 28, 1829 at the Tohickon Reformed Church
• Occupation:   Farmer, shoemaker
• Children: Jeremiah, Hannah, Nathan, Lucinda, Uriah

---

Nathan is something of an enigma; there is a surprising lack of information regarding him, which has made researching his life and his family difficult.  

Except for his tombstone in Allentown, no written record of his birth has been found to date.  Record of his marriage to Hannah Renner on June 28, 1829 at Tohickon Union Church exists in the records of this church.  He and Hannah are listed as sponsors at the baptism of one of their children at St. John’s Lutheran Church in Ridge Valley.  His name appears alongside that of his wife in the 1850 Census, but in the 1860 and 1870 Censuses he is no longer listed with Hannah.  In 1860, Hannah was living with her brother, John Renner, and in 1870 she was living with her son, Jeremiah.  

Nathan’s obituary, which appeared on page 1 of the February 20, 1899 edition of Allentown’s Morning Call, provides an explanation from this apparent disappearance from his family unit:

Nathan Thomas, one of the oldest residents of Allentown, died yesterday morning at the home of his granddaughter, Mrs. James Swinton, No. 20 Hamilton Street.  For the past four months he suffered much from dropsy, which affection, complicated with other ills due to his advanced years, caused his death. Deceased was born in Rockhill township, Bucks County, June 13, 1809, and was, therefore, in his 89^th year.  Early in life he learned the trade of shoemaking, which he followed up to the time he retired from active business pursuits, about fifteen years ago.  At different times he was located in towns in Bucks County. For several years prior to his removal to this city, twenty-two years ago, he followed his trade at Wesnersville, Berks county.  His wife preceded him to the grave about eight years ago. He was the last surviving member of the family. The following children survive: Jeremiah Thomas, Tylersport, Montgomery County; Mrs. Hannah Gerhart, Hatfield, and Mrs. William Moll, of Philadelphia; Ex-Police Officer Uriah Thomas, father of M. F. Thomas, the barber, who died four years ago, was a son.  There are also twenty-five grandchildren, twenty-six great grandchildren and one great great grandchild surviving. The deceased lived to see five generations of his descendants. The funeral will be held on Wednesday at 1:30 pm. Services will be held at his late home, Revs. F.D. Geary and Joseph Specht officiating.

Indeed, the 1860 Census confirms Nathan’s residence as Quakertown in Bucks County, and the 1870 Census places him in Albany Township in Berks County.  Both records indicate that he was living with his son, Uriah, who was also married and had several children by that time. As for why Nathan decided to leave and pursue work in neighboring counties, we may never know.  By the time he moved to Quakertown, his children were already old enough to have begun families and lives of their own; there was hardly a need for Nathan to stay at home to provide for young children. However, Nathan was also 50 years old at this time, and it is odd that he decided to move his trade elsewhere at this point in his life.

Nathan’s wife, Hannah, was the daughter of Adam (1780-1823) and Elizabeth (1775-1819) Renner and was one of at least ten children.  Church records indicate that she is buried at St. John’s Lutheran Church in Ridge Valley with many of her children and grandchildren.

Confirming Nathan’s Parents

The problem with having no record of Nathan’s birth (such as a birth certificate or baptismal record) is that the names of his parents become a mystery.  I have inferred that Nathan is Josiah’s son after extensive research, but no document has yet been found that confirms this relationship. 

There are several reasons why I believe that Josiah, the great-grandson of Elder William Thomas, was Nathan’s father.  The first is that I have extensively researched every other Thomas family that lived in Southeastern Pennsylvania from Colonial times through the mid-nineteenth century.  The name Nathan almost never appeared in these other family lines, and the one or two other Nathans that did appear were not born around 1809, did not marry someone by the name of Hannah Renner, and did not have a son named Jeremiah.  These are facts about “our” Nathan that are confirmed by his obituary and what few church records exist. Without meeting these criteria, any other Nathan Thomas is not the Nathan buried in Allentown, and thus is not “our” Nathan.

It is also very possible that Nathan was born out of wedlock.  Josiah and Elizabeth were married on November 21^st, 1809, but Nathan was born a few months earlier, on June 13 of the same year.  This theory is supported by the 1810 census. While these early census records did not give names besides that of the head of the household, they did tell how many other people resided in the household.  In 1810, three people resided in Josiah’s household: Josiah, one adult female (we shall presume his wife, Elizabeth), and one male child under the age of ten. We know that Josiah and Elizabeth’s other children were not born until 1811 or later, and we know that at the time of the 1810 census the couple had been married for only a few months.  Therefore, this young male child was likely born prior to their marriage. This may well be the first record we have of Nathan’s existence. 

While the occasion of a child’s birth before its parents’ marriage is certainly not unheard of at any point in history, one must consider the reaction of the family and of the community in general in the early nineteenth century, and, no less, in a region of the country steeped in strong religious beliefs.  How would Josiah’s family, descended from the strict Welsh Baptist minister, have reacted? Would the child have even been permitted to have been baptized? Would he have been permitted to be buried in sacred church ground? Would he have been permitted to be an active member of a church community? I have asked these questions of several ministers, and though unsure, they did believe it possible that Nathan may have been forbidden from any church activity or membership depending on the stringency of the minister or parish.  If Nathan’s participation in a church was limited, it would explain the surprising lack of church records, as well as why his funeral took place in his home and why he was buried in a city cemetery rather than with his family in Ridge Valley.

It is also a striking coincidence that Josiah, Nathan, and Nathan’s son, Jeremiah, were all married at the Tohickon Reformed Church.  This was the only apparent activity of any of these families at that church. Perhaps, since Josiah had been married here, the church permitted the marriage of Nathan and his son?  Or, perhaps it was a family tradition to be wed in this church? We may never know, but it is another link between Nathan and Josiah.

Children of Nathan Thomas and Hannah Renner

Jeremiah is discussed here.

Hannah was born on August 6, 1835 and died on October 19, 1907.  It can be inferred from Nathan’s obituary that she married a Mr. Gerhart.

Lucinda lived from 1843-1862.  From Nathan’s obituary we know that she married a Mr. William Moll. 

Nathan was born on January 5, 1846 and died July 30, 1878.  He married a woman by the name of Maggie. They, and an infant son named William Milton who was born and died in 1871, are buried in the Ridge Valley Cemetery.

Uriah married a woman named Sarah.  According to Nathan’s obituary he was a police officer and had a son “M. F. Thomas” who was a barber.

More on “The Trouble with Nathan”

I have chronicled my research into “The Nathan Problem” in a series of blogs:

• The Trouble with Nathan, Part 1
• The Trouble with Nathan, Part 2
• The Trouble with Nathan, Part 3
• The Trouble with Nathan, Conclusion

• Born: April 13, 1784 in Bucks County, Pennsylvania
• Died: August 20, 1856 in Hilltown, Bucks County, Pennsylvania (Buried at Hilltown Baptist Church “Lower” Cemetery)
• Spouse: Elizabeth Hoffman
  • Born: November 14, 1786
  • Died: November 6, 1855
• Married: November 21, 1809 at the Tohickon Reformed Church
• Children: Nathan, Silas, John, Martha, Joel, Mahlon, Oliver, Elizabeth, Mary
• Occupation:   Carpenter

---

Little is known about the life of Josiah Thomas.  He was born on April 13, 1784 and was a carpenter by trade.  He lived in several locations, the first being a log house built for him by his father, Asa.  Later in his life he purchased a small farm on a hill about a mile south of his original home.  

Josiah was married to Elizabeth Hoffman at the Tohickon Reformed Church on November 21, 1809, and they had several children.  Josiah died on August 20, 1856 at the age of 72. Elizabeth died on November 6, 1855 at the age of 69.

Children of Josiah Thomas and Elizabeth Hoffman

Nathan is discussed here.  It will be noted here, however, that no concrete documentation has been found to date that confirms that Nathan was Josiah’s son.  This inference has been made after lengthy research and due to the presence of very strong evidence.

Silas was born in 1811 and was a schoolteacher in many towns in Bucks and Montgomery counties, including Warrington, Gwynedd, Plymouth, and Whitemarsh, and later moved to Philadelphia.  He was married to Harriet Height and had five children: Dr. John S., William, Silas h., Lizzie, and Mary.

John was born in 1812 married three times.  His third wife was Margaret Murphy. He had several children: Levi, Maria, Martha, Olivia, and Caroline.  He died in 1866.

Martha married David Riale and died March 15, 1881 at the age of 68. 

Joel married Cathatine Herr.  Mahlon did not marry.  Elizabeth married John Holt.  Mary was born in 1822 and never married

Oliver was the youngest, born in 1830.  He did not marry. Though he was a bricklayer and mason by trade, in the early days of the Civil War he worked at the Tredegar Iron Works in Richmond, Virginia.  The Confederate army seized the factory and forced all its employees to produce ammunition. Initially, these workers were exempted from being drafted into the Confederate army.  Oliver sympathized with the north, and one day when he saw starving Union army prisoners being marched through the city he bought loaves of bread and handed slices to them as they passed.  He was imprisoned for a short time for doing so, and upon his release he returned to work at the iron works. By that time, Oliver and his fellow workers at the foundry were no longer exempted from the draft, and rather than serve in the Confederate army he planned an escape.  It was fortuitous that he knew a British subject, also from Wales and also bearing the surname Thomas. This Welshman gave Oliver his pass (the identification card of the day) that he used to escape to Philadelphia. He joined the Union army and served as a lieutenant and captain.  Shortly after the end of the war he died of consumption in Nebraska.

• Born: February 1758 in Hilltown, Bucks County, Pennsylvania
•  Died: May 8 or 10, 1839 in Hilltown, Bucks County, Pennsylvania (Buried at the Hilltown Baptist Church “Lower” Cemetery)
• Spouse: Martha James
  • Born: about 1765
  • Died: April 14, 1854, age 89
• Married:      around 1783
• Children:     Josiah, Margaret, Abel, Esther, Martha, Elizabeth, Asa, James, Catharine, and three others (two of whom were named Thomas and died young)
• Occupation:   Shoemaker, stone mason

---

Asa Thomas spent almost his entire life on family land.  He was born in 1758 in the house that his grandfather, Elder William Thomas, had built for his father, Thomas.  Asa was a stonemason and shoemaker by trade. It is said that he was short in stature, with broad shoulders, light brown hair, blue eyes, and a florid complexion.

Asa enlisted as a private in the American army at a young age.  He was 20 years old when he fought at the battle of Brandywine in September 1777.  The story goes that he was among the men ordered to guard the fords of the Brandywine creek, and that he became thirsty on the way back to their posts.  Rather than stopping at a tavern and risking an encounter with enemy soldiers, Asa stopped at a private home. When he was about to depart, he saw British soldiers entering the tavern and his host, a Quaker, led him to his safe escape behind a hedge at the rear of the house.

At the end of the Revolution, approximately the year 1783, he married Martha James, daughter of Abel James and Mary Howell and also of Welsh descent.  Asa and Martha lived in a log and stone house on Thomas family land. 

Asa spent his final days in a log home he built for his oldest son, Josiah, and died in May 1839 at the age of 82.  His wife, Martha, died on April 14, 1854, aged 89.

Children of Asa Thomas and Martha James

Asa and Martha had nine children who lived past childhood (listed below) and three others, two in succession who were named Thomas, who died very young. 

Josiah is discussed here.

Elizabeth was born in 1788 and married Isaac Miller.  Isaac was from Virginia and died on October 11, 1828.  They had one son, Thomas. Elizabeth later remarried Eleazar Bitting.  She died in New Britain on April 3, 1862.

Margaret was born in January 1797 and married Charles Hendricks in 1817.  Charles was a blacksmith and the family lived in various towns including Hilltown, Hatfield, and New Britain.  He died on October 31, 1844 of a fever. Margaret died on July 30, 1883. Their children were Thomas, Albert G., Martha, Oliver P., Samuel A., Benjamin J., and Elizabeth.

Martha was born on January 27, 1795 and married Henry Hohlbein.  Their children were John, James, Elvira, Eliza, Mary, and Susannah.  Martha died on May 23, 1868.

Abel was born on July 3, 1799.  He was the grandfather of Arthur K. Thomas, who published the book The Thomas Family of Hilltown.  Abel was a blacksmith and lived in various towns in both Bucks and Montgomery counties in the pursuit of work.  Before 1840 he lived in the village of Penllyn (just south of where the Penllyn railroad station stands) and was chosen by the Democratic party to be a Commissioner of the county.  He later moved to Doylestown and joined the New Britain Baptist church. He was also involved in the Pennsylvania volunteer militia beginning in 1830 and climbed through the ranks over the next decade.  On April 27, 1839 he was commissioned colonel of the Ninety-Second Regiment, Second Brigade, Second Division Militia of Bucks and Montgomery counties. He died on July 8, 1883 in Delaware County. Abel’s wife was Mary Craig, and their children were Albert, Allen, Asher, Ann Elizabeth, Ashbel C., Charles B., and Abel.

Asa was born on August 17, 1809 and married Ann Kulp of Gwynedd.  Their children were Asa, Franklin, Margaret, Annie, Mary, and Ellen.  He died on March 25, 1884.

James was born in May 1811.  He was a mason and never married.  He died in 1840 after a brief illness of pneumonia. 

Esther also never married and died of yellow fever in August 1810 when still a young woman.

Catharine was born in 1807 and married Samuel Kentner.  Their children were Benjamin, Judson, Samuel, Louisa, and Elvira.  She died in 1880 at the age of 73.